Skip to main content

Rice: Food or Fuel ?

Addressing Surplus Rice Stocks

The FCI’s warehouses are currently holding rice stocks that are nearly four times the required buffer stock. The high reserve price previously deterred purchases by ethanol distilleries and state agencies, which has exacerbated the surplus. By lowering the price, the government intends to:

  • Alleviate excess stocks.
  • Encourage more efficient distribution of rice to various stakeholders.
  • Enhance the affordability of raw materials for ethanol production.

Stock & Procurement

As of Nov 2024, Rice stock is 440.76 LMT, against the buffer norm of 102.50 LMT.


Reduction in Reserve Price of Rice under OMSS: A Strategic Step Towards Food Security and Sustainable Energy

In a significant move to address the surplus rice stocks and promote sustainable energy, the Indian government has announced a reduction in the reserve price of rice held by the Food Corporation of India (FCI) under the Open Market Sale Scheme (OMSS). The reserve price has been slashed by ₹550 per quintal, bringing it down from ₹2,800 to ₹2,250 per quintal for state governments and ethanol producers. This strategic decision aims to enhance food security, improve affordability, and stimulate the utilization of excess rice stocks.


Key Highlights of the Revised Pricing and Procurement Limits

Procurement Limits:

  • State governments and state-run corporations are allowed to procure up to 12 lakh tonnes of rice.
  • Ethanol distilleries are permitted to purchase up to 24 lakh tonnes of rice, a move that boosts ethanol production and aligns with India’s growing energy demands.

Effective Period:

  • The new pricing structure will remain in place until June 30, 2025.
  • FCI will manage the rice stocks through weekly e-auctions, ensuring a steady supply to eligible buyers.

Ethanol Production Focus:

  • The government has prioritized utilizing older FCI rice stocks for the third cycle tender of approximately 110 crore liters of ethanol for FY24-25.
  • This initiative contributes to India’s ethanol blending program, aimed at reducing reliance on fossil fuels and fostering environmental sustainability.


The Debate: Rice for Ethanol Production – Is It a Sustainable Option?

The utilization of rice for ethanol production has sparked a debate, balancing food security concerns with energy needs. The diversion of rice, a staple food for over half of the world's population, to ethanol production raises valid concerns about food security, water usage, and land utilization.

Logical Aspects:

  • Food vs. Fuel: While rice is vital for food security, using it for ethanol production could increase global food prices and lead to shortages, especially in countries where rice is a staple food.
  • Water Usage: Rice cultivation is water-intensive. Diverting it for ethanol production could further strain water resources in regions where water is already scarce.
  • Land Use: The large land area required for rice cultivation could lead to deforestation, loss of biodiversity, and other environmental consequences when repurposed for energy crops.

Technical Aspects:

  • Yield: Rice offers a relatively low ethanol yield per ton compared to other feedstocks like sugarcane or corn, making it less efficient for large-scale ethanol production.
  • Conversion Efficiency: The conversion efficiency of rice to ethanol is lower, resulting in higher production costs.
  • Energy Balance: The energy balance of rice-based ethanol production is often questioned. The energy required for cultivation, processing, and transportation may exceed the energy content of the ethanol produced.

Economic Aspects:

  • Cost: Rice-based ethanol production is more expensive than using other feedstocks, affecting its competitiveness in the market.
  • Subsidies: Government subsidies to support rice-based ethanol production may distort market prices, leading to economic inefficiencies.
  • Market Demand: The demand for rice-based ethanol may be limited, affecting the profitability of ethanol production facilities.


Alternative Sustainable Ethanol Production Sources

While rice can technically be used for ethanol production, there are more sustainable options to consider:

  1. Using Waste Biomass or Agricultural Residues: Agricultural residues and waste biomass can be a more efficient and sustainable feedstock for ethanol production.
  2. Cultivating Energy Crops on Marginal Lands: Growing energy crops like sorghum or switchgrass on marginal lands can reduce pressure on food crops and improve energy production.
  3. Improving Ethanol Production Efficiency: Optimizing existing ethanol production technologies can reduce costs and improve energy yields.
  4. Exploring Alternative Biofuels: Biofuels such as biodiesel or biogas from organic waste offer promising alternatives to ethanol.


Ethanol Production from Rice vs. Maize

Both rice and maize are viable sources for ethanol production, though they differ in their yield and production processes.

  1. Ethanol from Maize:
  • Yield: One tonne of maize produces around 380-400 liters of ethanol.
  • Production Process: Maize kernels are ground into powder, liquefied, and fermented to produce ethanol.
  • Uses: Ethanol from maize can be used as a fuel for generators or blended with gasoline to reduce costs.
      2. Ethanol from Rice:

    • Yield: One tonne of rice produces around 450-480 liters of ethanol.
    • Production Process: Rice straw is pretreated and fermented to convert sugars into ethanol.
    • Uses: Rice-based ethanol can be used as a biofuel additive for petrol or in the production of sanitizers.

     

    Market Dynamics and Impact on Crop Prices

    The reduced reserve price of rice for ethanol producers will have a significant impact on various agricultural markets:

    • White Rice Market: The market for IR varieties of white rice is expected to decline due to the reduced prices of rice under OMSS, leading to a potential shift in demand for higher-quality rice.
    • Maize: The price of maize is expected to see a downward trend just before the new crop arrivals in next 2 months, as the market adjusts to changes in demand for feedstock materials for ethanol production.

    Conclusion

    While the Indian government's decision to reduce the reserve price of rice for ethanol production may seem like a strategic move to address surplus stocks and promote energy sustainability, it raises important questions about food security, land use, and resource allocation. As India aims to increase its ethanol production and reduce reliance on fossil fuels, it is crucial to consider alternative feedstocks and more efficient production methods to balance energy needs with environmental and food security concerns.

    Exploring more sustainable ethanol production sources, such as agricultural residues and dedicated energy crops, will be vital for ensuring a long-term, sustainable energy future. By promoting a diversified approach to biofuels, the country can continue its push for cleaner energy while safeguarding its agricultural and food systems.

    Comments

    Popular posts from this blog

    Maize as Fuel of Future

      Ethanol as Fuel Government has set an ambitious target of 20% ethanol blending in petrol by 2025. This is a significant move to cut down the crude import which contribute to 25% of total import in terms of value in India. As of June this year, the national average for ethanol blending was 13%, an increase from previous year of 12.1% in 2022-23 and 10% in 2021-22. The blending ratios is reaching to nearly 16% by June 2024. What is important to understand that ethanol production in India initially relied predominantly molasses, a by-product of sugar production. The policy shift to include grains as supplementary feedstocks, such as maize and damaged rice, further diversifying the sources of ethanol has very prefound effect on raw material utilization for ethanol production. With government incentivise by setting a higher ex-distillery price of Rs 71.86 per liter for ethanol produced from maize, has led to the establishment of multi-feedstock distilleries, which operate on a m...

    Technology - Advising Farmers and Crop Yield Assesment

    Food security in the light of climate change is a global imperative. In developing nations, the problem is exacerbated by variable weather, lack of reliable extension services to optimize yield and fair market access. In India, most farmers do not have access to weather advisory forecasts that are hyper local to their field and timely in nature. As all farming activities are heavily dependent on weather, decisions on application of fertilizers and pesticide, irrigation, and even plucking of fruits & vegetables and harvesting cannot be taken efficiently. In addition, significant crop losses, that are entirely preventable, accrue through adverse weather events. Crop advisory services, where available, are generic and not pegged to a farmer's seed variety, date of sowing, and growing conditions and hence do not dispense timely, actionable advice, directly relevant to a farmer. Likewise, market trends pertinent to their particular crop and location ...

    MONSOON 2024

    India is poised to have a good monsoon this year. It can be seen for the NOAA graph of Fig. 1 below. El Nino conditions are changing to La Nina from May June July. Fig. 1: ENSO Probabilities by NOAA This year, the Southwest Monsoon is anticipated to arrive in extreme parts of South-SE Bay around the first week of May, gradually progressing northward. Seasonal Forecast as given by IRI in Fig. 2 below. Fig. 2: Seasonal Forecast by IRI Regional Outlook: The monsoon season may extend into early October this year. Western and Northwestern India: Above-normal to excess rainfall is possible over most parts of Western and Northwestern India, including Gujarat, Rajasthan, Punjab, Maharashtra, Telangana, Madhya Pradesh, and Chhattisgarh. This increased Rains is likely to raise concerns for potential flooding, especially during the peak and late monsoon seasons. Rains are likely to be favorable to all Kharif Crops. Fig. 3: Rainfall forecast by IMD Southern and Southeastern India: While the ...